ATO benchmark, 2023-24 financial year
ATO small business benchmarks for panel beating and smash repairs
The ATO's 2023-24 benchmark for panel beating and smash repairs puts total expenses at 51% to 73% of turnover for a business turning over A$150,001 to A$300,000. The average for that band is 62%. Below that, in the A$50,000 to A$150,000 band, the range is 46% to 67%; above it, for turnover of more than A$300,000, it is 73% to 86%.
The panel beating and smash repairs ranges are drawn from 2023-24 tax returns and were the latest available when this page was compiled in November 2026.
1.0 Benchmark ranges by turnover band
Each cell shows the share of annual turnover, GST excluded, that the ATO found typical for that expense among panel beating and smash repairs businesses, and the column to read is the one that matches your own turnover.
| Ratio to turnover | A$50,000 to A$150,000 | A$150,001 to A$300,000 | More than A$300,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost of sales | 17% to 31% | 19% to 35% | 34% to 45% |
| Total expenses (key) | 46% to 67% | 51% to 73% | 73% to 86% |
| Average total expenses | 57% | 62% | 80% |
| Labour | 21% to 33% | 18% to 29% | 20% to 29% |
| Rent | 12% to 19% | 9% to 15% | 4% to 7% |
| Motor vehicle expenses | 5% to 8% | 4% to 6% | 1% to 3% |
Source: ATO small business benchmarks, 2023-24. Blank ratios are not published for this industry.
Blue bar: published range. Gold marker: band average where the ATO gives one.
1.1 Who the ATO counts as panel beating and smash repairs
The ATO places a business in the panel beating and smash repairs benchmark using its business industry code and keywords in the trading name and activity description on the return, and describes the group this way:
Businesses in this industry provide motor vehicle smash repairs, panel beating, spray painting and restorations.
2.0 What each ratio means for panel beating and smash repairs
Total expenses is the broadest of the ratios, and in the panel beating and smash repairs category a business turning over A$225,000 would sit inside the range with expenses of A$114,750 to A$164,250, which is 51% to 73% of sales, and the ATO excludes payments to associated persons before it divides.
The band averages for panel beating and smash repairs run 57%, then 62%, then 80% as turnover rises, a change of 23 percentage points from the lowest band to the highest. The usual reason for a climb like that is labour, since a one-person panel beating and smash repairs business keeps what is left as the owner's income and a larger one has turned much of that into wages and contractor costs. At the middle band average of 62%, a panel beating and smash repairs business has about 38 cents in each dollar of sales left before the owner's own pay and income tax, or roughly A$85,500 on A$225,000 of turnover.
The panel beating and smash repairs cost of sales ratio covers trading stock and materials only, with no labour in it: at 19% to 35%, that is A$42,750 to A$78,750 of purchases on A$225,000 of sales, and the midpoint ranks 65th of 71 industries with this ratio. It is a secondary ratio here; the key ratio the ATO uses for panel beating and smash repairs is total expenses.
The panel beating and smash repairs labour range, which counts salary and wages plus contractor, sub-contractor and commission payments less anything paid to associated persons, is 18% to 29% in the A$150,001 to A$300,000 band, or A$40,500 to A$65,250 a year on A$225,000 of turnover. Across bands the labour share for panel beating and smash repairs is highest for turnover of A$50,000 to A$150,000 (21% to 33%), and its mid-band midpoint ranks 26th of the 50 industries with a labour ratio.
Rent for panel beating and smash repairs sits at 9% to 15% of turnover in the A$150,001 to A$300,000 band, which is A$20,250 to A$33,750 a year on A$225,000 of sales. From the lowest panel beating and smash repairs band to the highest the rent share falls, from 12% to 19% to 4% to 7%. Premises are largely a fixed cost for panel beating and smash repairs, so the share shrinks as sales grow.
Motor vehicle expenses run at 4% to 6% of turnover for panel beating and smash repairs in the A$150,001 to A$300,000 band, about A$9,000 to A$13,500 on A$225,000 of sales, placing it 29th of 100 industries on this ratio.
3.0 How to work out your own ratios
For panel beating and smash repairs, as for every benchmark, the sum is the expense divided by turnover excluding GST, times 100, and the figures to use are those on the business schedule of the tax return, because the ATO builds the ranges from return labels and not from bank statements.
Total expenses claimed (less any payments to associated persons): A$139,500
A$139,500 ÷ A$225,000 × 100 = 62.0%
Published range for A$150,001 to A$300,000: 51% to 73%. Result: inside the range.
Cost of sales A$61,000 ÷ A$225,000 × 100 = 27.1% against a range of 19% to 35%.
Two adjustments matter when a panel beating and smash repairs business runs this check: turnover means sales of goods and services (the A$225,000 in the example), so interest, asset sales and government payments stay out unless they are most of the income. And if you are a sole trader, your own drawings are not an expense, which is why a small panel beating and smash repairs business can show a ratio well under the larger bands.
4.0 If your figure falls outside the range
A total expenses ratio above 73% for a panel beating and smash repairs business in this band means expenses are high for the sales reported, and the ATO lists the ordinary causes as wastage, stock taken for private use, paying more for inputs than competitors, low mark-up, and sales that were not all recorded. Because total expenses is the key ratio for panel beating and smash repairs, it is also the one the ATO uses to pick out returns where income may be under-reported, so a figure well above 73% is the result most likely to draw a question.
A result under 51% is not a problem in itself: it can mean better buying or pricing than the typical panel beating and smash repairs business, though it is worth checking that every expense made it onto the return. Keep the width of the range in mind: the ATO draws it around the 30% of panel beating and smash repairs businesses closest to the band average, so most of the population sits outside it on one side or the other.
Treat a result outside the panel beating and smash repairs range as a prompt to check the records, not as proof of a mistake; the ATO itself states that benchmarks are never the sole basis for reviewing a business.
5.0 How the total expenses range has moved
Between 2021-22 and 2023-24 the total expenses range for panel beating and smash repairs in the middle band went from 54% to 51% at the bottom (down 3 points) and went from 76% to 73% at the top (down 3 points). A shift of that size is worth knowing about if you last checked a panel beating and smash repairs business against an older table.
6.0 Industries with similar ratios
Ranked by the midpoint of the total expenses range in the middle band, the panel beating and smash repairs benchmark is 86th of the 100 benchmark industries, where 1st carries the heaviest expense load; its closest neighbours on that measure are listed below.
| Industry | Key ratio | Total expenses | Band |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cleaning services (building and other industrial) | total expenses | 46% to 69% | A$115,001 to A$250,000 |
| Bricklaying services | total expenses | 51% to 68% | A$150,001 to A$350,000 |
| Courier services | total expenses | 48% to 71% | A$100,001 to A$300,000 |
| Tiling services (floor and wall) | total expenses | 53% to 71% | A$150,001 to A$600,000 |
| Chiropractic and osteopathic services | total expenses | 54% to 71% | A$200,001 to A$600,000 |
| Painting services | total expenses | 54% to 71% | A$150,001 to A$600,000 |
To put a number on the panel beating and smash repairs category, the nearest ABS industry class is Automotive Body, Paint and Interior Repair (ANZSIC 9412), with 14,479 businesses operating at June 2025. That match is ours, and the ABS class is not defined the same way as the ATO's panel beating and smash repairs group, so read the two sets of figures side by side, not as one population.
7.0 Questions on these figures
7.1 What is the ATO benchmark for panel beating and smash repairs with turnover of more than A$300,000?
For more than A$300,000 the total expenses range is 73% to 86% of turnover (average 80%), based on 2023-24 returns.
7.2 How much of turnover do panel beating and smash repairs spend on labour?
The ATO labour range for panel beating and smash repairs is 21% to 33% for A$50,000 to A$150,000; 18% to 29% for A$150,001 to A$300,000; 20% to 29% for more than A$300,000.
7.3 Did the panel beating and smash repairs benchmark change between 2022-23 and 2023-24?
In the middle band the total expenses range was 56% to 75% in 2022-23 and 51% to 73% in 2023-24.
7.4 Which ratio does the ATO treat as the key benchmark for panel beating and smash repairs?
Total expenses to turnover is the key ratio for panel beating and smash repairs, the one the ATO regards as the best predictor of turnover in the industry.
8.0 Sources
- Australian Taxation Office, Small business benchmarks: Panel beating and smash repairs, 2023-24 financial year. ato.gov.au Licence: ATO copyright notice permits reuse with attribution.
- Australian Taxation Office, Small Business Benchmarks data files, 2021-22 to 2023-24, data.gov.au. data.gov.au Licence: CC BY 2.5 AU.
- Australian Bureau of Statistics, Counts of Australian Businesses, including Entries and Exits, July 2021 to June 2025, data cubes 1 to 5 (detail released December 2025). abs.gov.au Licence: CC BY 4.0.
- Australian Taxation Office, Small business benchmarks methodology and ratio calculations. ato.gov.au
- Australian Taxation Office, What it means to be outside the benchmark range. ato.gov.au
- Australian Taxation Office, How we use business performance benchmarks. ato.gov.au
Compiled November 2026. Figures are reproduced or calculated from the sources listed; the publishing agency is the authority if anything here differs from its own release. Report an error.